U.S. card acceptance / a statement-first journal
LAUNCH EDITION · 15 NOV 2026
Guides

Flat rate or interchange-plus? Run the same basket.

The cheaper model depends on your inputs, not on which pricing label sounds more transparent.

U.S. / USDPrepared 15 Nov 20262 min read
The cheaper model depends on your inputs, not on which pricing label sounds more transparent.

The price label is not the answer

Start with two fictional quotes. Quote A charges 2.70% plus 10¢ with no monthly fee. Quote B uses an assumed underlying cost of 1.80%, then adds a 0.35% processor margin, 8¢ per payment and $25 per month. The 1.80% input is a scenario assumption, not a live interchange benchmark.

At $40,000 and 800 successful payments, A costs $1,160. B costs $949. The $211 difference is valid only for those assumptions. Raise the underlying cost in B to 2.40% and its total becomes $1,189; the apparent winner changes.

Keep percentage and cents separate

A percentage charge grows with the dollar value. A fixed event charge grows with the event count. In a spreadsheet, preserve both columns rather than converting every fee to a percentage too early. A shop with 4,000 small purchases and a contractor with 80 invoices can have the same monthly revenue and a very different bill.

ScenarioA: 2.70% + 10¢B: assumed 1.80% + 0.35% + 8¢ + $25
$40,000 / 800 payments$1,160$949
$40,000 / 4,000 payments$1,480$1,205
$5,000 / 100 payments$145$140.50

What a published plus price represents

Helcim publishes a processor margin on top of interchange, with tiers. That structure is useful for understanding the distinction between a margin and an all-in quote; it does not mean the margin alone can be compared with another provider’s bundled rate.

Make the hidden assumptions visible

A quote model should say whether the pass-through input contains percentage and fixed amounts, network fees and any international component. In our tool the pass-through percentage is an assumed combined underlying cost. Do not add the same cost twice if it is already reflected there.

Keep fixed charges outside the rate column. Hardware, gateway plans, chargeback administration and exit fees may need their own calculation. Unknown is not zero: leave a clear open question in the comparison worksheet.

Calculate a break-even only when the model supports it

For a stable average ticket T, a simplified monthly model is volume × (percentage + per-payment fee ÷ T) + fixed fee. The intersection of two such lines is useful only if the average ticket and assumptions remain constant. When transaction sizes vary widely, evaluate the transaction export instead.

There may be no positive break-even. One quote can be more expensive over the whole range you are testing. Do not manufacture a crossing point to make a calculator look more decisive.

Saved locally when checked.

Keep the decision memo short

Record the inputs, the resulting dollar difference, two assumptions that could reverse it, and the unanswered contractual questions. That is more useful to an owner than a universal claim that one pricing model always saves money.

Frequently asked questions

Is interchange-plus always cheaper?
No. Card mix, volume, average sale, margin and recurring charges can reverse the result.
Can a flat rate change by channel?
Yes. Compare the actual contracted in-person, keyed, online and other channel prices rather than treating a provider as one number.

Check the source.

Sources consulted for this edition. Public prices are not personalized quotes; a source’s original date and its retrieval date are separate.

Helcim · pricing ↗Helcim · U.S. fee disclosures ↗Square · U.S. fees by plan and channel ↗Mastercard · interchange explained ↗

Checked 2026-11-15 · Read the methodology